Electric Cars: Worth It Environmentally?
This is a question I've been thinking about for quite some time now. Electric cars are great for the end user, but what impacts do they have that the owner doesn't see? We'll be looking at how the electricity is produced and whether having an electric car is better for the environment.
I'm going to be omitting any renewable energy source since they don't produce any emissions. This includes solar, wind, and hydro. Depending on where you live your electricity may be produced from nuclear or (gulp) coal.
Please keep in mind that these are theoretical calculations and the real world results may be better or worse than what we find out here. I will be including efficiency data so we can get as close to real world as possible.
First, we'll set our boundaries. You'll drive the car 6 days a week on average for 30 minutes a day. The car gets 28MPG (average city/highway) and you travel (on average) 30MPH. We'll use 312 days so we can clearly see the results.
The electric car will be using 20Kwh of energy per hour driving the same speed (I think it's higher). Everything else stays the same.
We'll start with gas first so we have a baseline to compare to. Each gallon of gas emits about 8.6Kg worth of carbon dioxide. Over a years worth of driving you will emit about 8,600Kg worth of carbon dioxide.
Next we'll move on to an electric car whose electricity is produced from a coal burning plant. Each Kg of coal produces roughly 2Kwh of energy. Each Kg of coal also produces 1.83Kg worth of CO2 emissions. That means driving your electric car with electricity from a coal fired plant is going to produce 17,128Kg worth of CO2 emissions. That's over double of just using gasoline! The economic upside of this is that electricity is much cheaper than gas so it will save you money... for now.
I would like to be able to compare to nuclear power, but it uses a different process. Sure there are almost zero (?) emissions; however, the spent uranium is still radioactive for many years afterwards. This isn't necessarily a bad thing as there are regulations for handling of nuclear waste, but you can help but wonder "what if"?
If you want an electric car you should probably check out how your electricity is produced. By buying one you could be causing more damage than you think.
If you liked this article consider signing up for our newsletter. Simply enter your information below.
I will never rent or sell your information. I hate spam too!
|



Comments
AGREE
Why go electric?
Even with what you're saying
Even with what you're saying the car would still use 9kw per hour.
I will go digging up my sources and list them here.
That being said, I did take into account a coal fired plant and the electricity used by it, but I obviously didn't go down the whole electricity food chain.
Even if you only use 10kwh driving at 30mph your carbon emissions would still be equal to gas if you're using coal fired power.
Actual EV energy Consumption - 2 samples
charging
That's some good info,
electric cars & co2
Post new comment